good? bad? I don't even know... it has the energy of The Force Awakens, but it's very sloppy. it's daring like The Last Jedi, but it doesn't subvert or has any substance behind it's choices.
it's a mess, a fun mess... a frustrating mess, and it's a lot to take in.... some of it feels unearned, some of it feels like a betrayal of previous movies, especially The Last Jedi and it's themes, but some of it feels like vidication of fandom for the sake of vindication in the eyes of the fandom.
it tried to please everyone and ends up... well, your mileage may vary and I can so... SOOO exahusted...